Finkelstein, Meirowitz & Eidlisz

Finkelstein, Meirowitz & Eidlisz

NYC Workers’ Compensation & Social Security Disability Lawyers

New York City Workers’ Compensation
& Social Security Disability Lawyers

(212) 385-9190

  • Home
  • About Us
    • About Irving Finkelstein, Esq.
    • About Mark Eidlisz, Esq.
    • Reviews
  • Workers’ Compensation
    • Workers Comp FAQs
    • Workers’ Compensation Office Locations
    • Workers’ Compensation Denials
    • File a Claim
  • Social Security Disability
    • Social Security Disability FAQs
  • Blog
  • Contact Us

What are common defenses that employers raise to defeat a workers’ compensation claim?

Aug 10, 2018 Jordan Weinstein

Workers’ compensation defenses are called C-7 issues.

Under Workers’ Compensation Law Section 21, injured workers are entitled to a presumption that an injury arose out of his or her workplace. The lawyers for the workers’ compensation insurance carrier would have to present some kind of evidence showing that your injury didn’t happen in the workplace.

For example, if the employee claims to have been injured in a motor vehicle accident in connection with work, the insurance company may produce a video showing that there was no accident in an effort to defeat the claim.

Under workers’ compensation laws, the general rule is that you have 30 days from your injury to provide notice of the incident to your employer, whether it be in writing or orally. If those 30 days pass, and you don’t have a good reason for not informing your employer, your claim might be time-barred.

Also in workers’ compensation cases, after giving notice of the injury to the employer, in most cases you have two years fromthe date of the injury to file a claim. This may vary in certain situations and employers, so be sure to speak with an experienced workers’ compensation lawyer as soon as possible to make sure that not too much time has passed to make a claim.

If you file a claim three years afterthe date of injury, especially if you didn’t provide evidence to the employer at the time, you may be barred under Workers’ Compensation Law Section 28 from bringing a claim.

The workers’ compensation insurer may also raise the question of whether the injury arose out of your job. For example, if you make a claim for a back injury suffered on the job, the lawyers for the insurance company may try to produce evidence showing that the injury was caused by playing basketball, not at work.

The insurance company may raise the argument that either you’re not an employee, you never worked there, or you’re an independent contractor. This would then require a fact-based determination on whether you’re an independent contractor or an employee.

There are other defenses that a workers’ compensation insurance company may raise to minimize your benefits. For example, you may have an accepted injury, but the insurer is arguing that you shouldn’t be entitled to any wage loss benefits because you had stopped working due to being terminated, or you stopped working to retire, regardless of the workplace injury.

workers' compensation

Contact Us

Finkelstein, Meirowitz & Eidlisz, LLP
P.O. Box 309
Old Westbury, NY 11568

(212) 385-9190 phone
(212) 233-5862 fax

Contact Us

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Recent Posts

  • Is it important that I have an attorney representing me in my workers’ comp case or can I do it myself?
  • How are New York workers’ comp benefits calculated?
  • Workers’ Compensation Insurance – Minimizing Your Benefits & Insurance Fraud
  • What are common defenses that employers raise to defeat a workers’ compensation claim?
  • Can I go to my own doctor if I have a workers’ compensation injury?

Contact Us

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Call us at (212) 385-9190

We proudly serve all of New York City including The Bronx, Brooklyn, Harlem, Manhattan, Queens, and Staten Island.
P.O. Box 309 | Old Westbury, NY 11568 | (212) 385-9190

Disclaimer | Privacy Policy

ATTORNEY ADVERTISING

©2025 Finkelstein, Meirowitz & Eidlisz. All Rights Reserved.